* Indicates National Champion

1951
Marvin Solganik, All-American, Soccer

1972-73
Greg Bowser, NCAA All-American Small College Champion, Cross Country
Richard Evans, NCAA All-American, Track (High Jump)
Chuck Williams, NCAA All-American, Track (Pole Vault)

1973-74
Greg Bowser, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Chuck Williams, NCAA All-American, Track (Decathlon)

1974-75
Greg Bowser, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Richard Evans, NCAA All-American, Track (High Jump)
Doug Leary, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Eric Richardson, NCAA All-American, Track (Long Jump, Triple Jump)
Jeff Tanchon, NCAA All-American, Cross Country

1975-76
Peter Kummant, NCAA All-American, Cross Country

1976-77
Peter Kummant, NCAA All-American, Cross Country, NCAA All-American, Track (10,000 meters)

1977-78
Mark Koenig, NCAA All-American, Track
Peter Kummant, NCAA All-American, Cross Country

1978-79
Doug Gergel, NCAA All-American, Track (Pole Vault)

1979-80
Doug Conrad, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Andrew Katz, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football

Tom McDuffee, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Tom Robinson, NCAA All-American, Swimming

1980-81
Doug Conrad, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Tom Robinson, NCAA All-American, Swimming

1981-82
Lisa Bernard, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Clark Brumbaugh, NCAA All-American, Wrestling
Tom Robinson, NCAA All-American, Swimming

1982-83
Mike Bukuts, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Jeff Heymann, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Football
John Libenthal, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Football
Scott Ockington, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Tom Robinson, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Ron Stepanovic, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football

1983-84
Fred DiSanto, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
Jim Donnelly, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Football
Fred Manley, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Pizza Hut All-American (Second), Football
Mark Raiff, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Pizza Hut All-American (First), Football
Ron Stepanovic, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football

1984-85
Fred DiSanto, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Fred Manley, Associated Press Little All-American (First), Kodak All-American (First), Football
Mark Raiff, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Football
Ron Stepanovic, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Dave Stuczynski, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football

1985-86
Elizabeth Biegelsen, Adidas All-American (First), Soccer
Kevin Ferguson, NCAA All-American Div. III, Outdoor Track
Erwin Grabisna, NCAA All-American Div. III, Indoor/Outdoor Track
Mark Raiff, Associated Press Little All-American (First), Pizza Hut All-American (Second), Football
Anthony Rus, Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
Ron Stepanovic, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (First), Football
Dave Stuczynski, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (Second), Football
Jay Todd, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Mike Weber, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football

1986-87
Elizabeth Biegelsen, Adidas All-American (HM), Soccer
Michael Ciani, Football News All-American (First), Associated Press Little All-American (Third), Football
Kevin Ferguson, NCAA All-American Div. III, Outdoor Track (Javelin)
Erwin Grabisna, Associated Press Little All-American (Second), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football, NCAA All-American, Track (Discus, 35 Lb. Throw, Hammer)
Timothy Lynch, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
John Moore, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
John Polivka, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
Anthony Rus, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
Jay Todd, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
*Vincent Van Burik, NCAA All-American, Track (800 meter run)

 1987-88
*John Bradshaw, NCAA All-American, Swimming (*100, 200 Butterfly) and NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free, 200 Medley, 800 Free, 400 Medley)
Wes Cherry, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free, 200 Medley, 800 Free, 400 Medley)
Enrique Conterno, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free, 200 Medley, 800 Free, 400 Medley)
Guy Genin, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free, 200 Medley)
Paul Hudak, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (800 Free, 400 Medley)
Erwin Grabisna, NCAA All-American, Indoor/Outdoor Track (Hammer, Discus, 35 Lb. Throw)
Football News All-American (Second), Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football
Kevin Luthy, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (High Jump)
Scott Miller, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (150 lbs.)
Vincent Van Burik, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (800 meter run)

 1988-89
*John Bradshaw, NCAA All-American, Swimming (*100 & 200 Butterfly) and NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 IM)
Guy Genin, NCAA All-American, Swimming (400 IM)
Greg Hanchin, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (177 lbs.)
Chris Hutter, Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football News All-American (HM), Football
Mike Imburgia, Football News All-American (Second), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Kevin Luthy, NCAA All-American, Track (Decathlon)
Scott Miller, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (158 lbs.)
Steve Rosiek, Football News All-American (First), Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Football
Paul Washlock, Associated Press Little All-American (HM), Pizza Hut All-American (HM), Football

 1989-90
*Sheila Ballado, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (100 Hurdles)
Guy Genin, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 & 400 IM, 200 Breast)
Jay Gindin, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Butterfly)
*Kevin Luthy, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Decathlon)
Jamie Meek, Football Gazette All American (HM), Football
Ed Saxon, Basketball Gazette All-American (Second) and NABC All-American (HM), Basketball

1990-91
Marc Anderson, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Shot Put)
Guy Genin, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (400 IM)
Lisa Encarnacion, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (100 Hurdles)
Josh Foster, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free Relay)
Peter Johnson, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free Relay)
Kevin Luthy, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Decathlon)
Shannon Pisone, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free Relay)
Basil Strasburg, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Free Relay)

1991-92

Ed Trebets, Football Gazette All-American (HM), Football
Rich Zdrojewski, Football Gazette All-American (HM), Football
Wes Cherry, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (100 & 200 Breast, 200 & 400 Medley Relays)
Lisa Encarnacion, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (55 meter hurdles)
Josh Foster, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Freestyle, 200 & 400 Medley Relays)
*Jay Gindin, NCAA All-American, Swimming (100 & *200 Butterfly, 200 & 400 Medley Relays)
Pete Johnson, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Freestyle Relay)
Leslie Kindling, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Triple Jump)
Steve Pohnert, NCAA All-American, Swimming (1650 Free)
Basil Strasburg, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Freestyle Relay)
Darren Trokhan, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Freestyle Relay)
Mark VanArsdale, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Butterfly, 200 & 400 Medley Relays)

1992-93
Jay Gindin, NCAA All-American, Swimming (200 Butterfly) and NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (100 Butterfly)
Leslie Kindling, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (High Jump) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (High Jump)
Sue Waniewski, National Soccer Coaches Assn. of America (Third)

1993-94
Susan Beatty, NCAA All-American, Swimming (500 Freestyle) and NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (400 IM, 1650 Free)
Dave Ciacci, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (134 lbs.)
Steve Cullen, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Ed Kalaher, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (Shot Put) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Shot Put, Discus)
Leslie Kindling, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (High Jump) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (High Jump, Heptathlon)
*Chris Ricklic, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (167 lbs.)
Rich Zdrojewski, Football Gazette All-American (HM), Football

1994-95
Susan Beatty, NCAA All-American, Swimming (500 & 1650 Freestyle) and NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (400 IM)
Brian Casselberry, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (10K) and Cross Country Coaches All-American, Cross Country
Steve Cullen, Cross Country Coaches All-American, Cross Country
Kevin Eppig, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (200 Back)
Ed Kalaher, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (Shot Put) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Shot Put)
*Leslie Kindling, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (*High Jump) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (High Jump, *Heptathlon)
*Chris Ricklic, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (167 lbs.)
Sharon Sanborn, NCAA All-American (HM), Swimming (100 Freestyle)

1995-96
Susan Beatty, NCAA All-American, Swimming (500 & 1650 Freestyle, 400 IM)
Ed Kalaher, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (Shot Put) and NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (Shot Put)
*Derek Messmer, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (Hwt.)
Sharon Sanborn, NCAA All-American, Swimming (100 Fly)

1996-97
Derek Messmer, Football Gazette All-American (HM), Football
Susan Beatty, NCAA All-American, Swimming (500 & 1650 Freestyle, 400 IM)
Sharon Sanborn, NCAA All-American, Swimming (100 Fly)

1998-99
Kelly Alexander, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Matthew Anderson, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Tom Courtad, Hewlett Packard All-American, Associated Press Little All-American (Third), Football
Jon Gellin, NCAA All-American, Swimming

1999-2000
Kelly Alexander, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Christine Conageski, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Lisa Gieseker, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Veronica Luri, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Jake Peterson, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Meredith Stakem, NCAA All-American, Swimming

2000-01
Kelly Alexander, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Liz Badziong, NCAA All-American, Swimming
John Gellin, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Lisa Gieseker, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Zak Kallai, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (149 lbs.)
Ellen Kaminski, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Alicia Kendig, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Meghan Kerner, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Veronica Luri, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Chris Nader, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (157 lbs.)
Kristen Prijatel, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Meredith Stakem, NCAA All-American, Swimming
David Whitbeck, NCAA All-American, Swimming

2001-02
Kelly Alexander, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Matt Anderson, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Liz Badziong, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Chris Cook, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Nate Davis, NCAA All-American, Swimming
John Gellin, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Lisa Gieseker, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Elaine Hillenmeyer, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Zak Kallai, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (149 lbs.)
Alicia Kendig, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Veronica Luri, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Michael Monaghan, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Chris Nader, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (157 lbs.)
JeNine Nickerson, Kodak All-American, Basketball

2002-03
Liz Badziong, NCAA All-American, Swimming (400 IM, 800 Free Relay)
Lisa Gieseker, NCAA All-American, Swimming (1650 Freestyle)
Eli Grant, Football Gazette All-American (Third), D3Football.com (Third), Hewlett Packard All-American (HM), Football
Elaine Hillenmeyer, NCAA All-American, Swimming (400 Medley Relay, 800 Free Relay)
Zak Kallai, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (149 lbs.)
*Alicia Kendig, NCAA All-American, Swimming (200, *500, 1650 Free, 400 & 800 Free Relays)
Kristen Prijatel, NCAA All-American, Swimming (400 Medley Relay, 800 Free Relay)
Steve Schindler, Hewlett Packard All-American (HM), Football
Meredith Stakem, NCAA All-American, Swimming (100 Free, 400 Medley Relay,400 & 800 Free Relays)
Hannah Webber, NCAA All-American, Swimming (400 Medley Relay, 800 Free Relay)

2003-04
Zak Kallai, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (149 lbs.)
Pat Rodjom, NCAA All-American, Swimming
Dave Whitbeck, NCAA All-American, Swimming

2004-05
Aaron Johnston-Peck, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
John Keltz, NCAA All-American (100 Breast)

2005-06
Pat Rodjom, NCAA All-American (100 Breast)

2006-07
Joe Brenner, Football Gazette All-American (Third), Football 
Tom Brew, Football Gazette All-American (First), D3Football.com (Third), Football 
Elizabeth Ehrke, NCAA All-American, Track (Discus)
Esther Erb, NCAA All-American, Cross Country & Track (5,000-meter)
John Erickson, NCAA All-American, Swimming(50-yard freestyle)
Stephanie Nothelle, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Lauren Preyss, NCAA All-American, Swimming (50, 100, & 200-yard freestyle)
Pat Rodjom, NCAA All-American, Swimming (100 Breast)

2007-2008
Tom Brew, D3Football.com (Third), Football
*Esther Erb, NCAA All-American, Cross Country & Track (5,000-meter & *10,000 meter)
Matt Paglia ,NSCAA 3rd Team All-American, Men's Soccer
Dave Manoogian, NCAA All-American, Wrestling (141 lbs.)

2008-2009
Bobby Bott, American Football Coaches Association All-American, Football
Justine Jeroski, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Britta Kumley, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Obinna Nwanna, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (pentathlon)
Alex Hostoffer, NCAA All-American, Swimming & Diving (200-yard breaststroke)
Drew Gardella, NCAA All-American, Wrestling
Erin Hollinger, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track & Field (high jump)
Obinna Nwanna, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track & Field (decathlon)

2009-2010
Dan Whalen, American Football Coaches Association All-American, D3Football.com (First), Football
Tony Opperman, D3Football.com (HM), Football
Justine Jeroski, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Elaine Simpson, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Obinna Nwanna, NCAA All-American, Indoor Track (pentathlon)
* Isaac Dukes, NCAA All-American, Wrestling *
* Obinna Nwanna, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track (decathlon)

2010-2011
Justine Jeroski, NCAA All-American, Cross Country
Vinny Bell, NSCAA Third Team, Men's Soccer
Isaac Dukes, NCAA All-American, Wrestling
Erin Hollinger, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track & Field (high jump)
Lauren Wolz, NFCA Third-Team, Softball
Chad Mullins, ABCA First-Team/D3Baseball.com Player of the Year

2011-2012
Kendra Simmons, NSCAA Third Team, Women's Soccer
Niro Wimalasena, NSCAA Second Team, Men's Soccer
Vinny Bell, NSCAA Second Team, Men's Soccer
Erin Hollinger, NCAA All-American, Women's Track & Field (high jump)
Matt Jurcak, NCAA All-American, Men's Track & Field (60m hurdles)
Isaac Dukes, NCAA All-American, Wrestling
Erin Hollinger, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track & Field (high jump)
Matt Jurcak, NCAA All-American, Outdoor Track & Field (110m hurdles)

2012-2013
Evy Iacono, D3Hoops.com Honorable Mention, Women's Basketball

*Indicates National Champion